Thursday, September 1, 2011

Hub Population Health System - Query Health Summer Concert Series

The New York City Department of Health's Hub Population Health System ("The Hub") enables the distribution of electronic health record queries, targeted clinical decision support, and secure messages to more than 350 small practices and large community health centers using eClinicalWorks in New York City, covering 1.1 million patients. Query results are received as aggregate counts for population health purposes. Over 600 unique queries have been run over 80,000 times covering the areas of population health evaluation, EHR system utilization, Hub system performance, syndromic surveillance, etc. Jesse Singer and Michael Buck present

Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Population CCR - Query Health Summer Concert Series

Population CCR is an approach for simplifying and integrating performance reporting and decision support. It fulfills a need for decoupling of analytics from current and future health IT systems. It eases the creation of rules by non-programmers and harmonizes the representation of clinical data across patient records, performance reporting, and decision support - all by using widely accepted standard technologies. Steven Waldren presents.


Query Health - Population CCR Presentation from S&I Framework on Vimeo.

Tuesday, August 30, 2011

caGrid - Query Health Summer Concert Series

caGrid is an open‐source framework that addresses the needs of a heterogeneous community to access, integrate, and analyze biomedical data of diverse nature and source. This platform allows diverse, authorized applications, running on multiple platforms, to access appropriate data (both individual level and aggregated) from distributed sources. It permits simple access to unrestricted data using standard internet technology as well as secure access by authorized “virtual communities” to sensitive, restricted digital resources using community‐developed caGrid technology. Ken Buetow presents.


Query Health - caGrid Presentation from S&I Framework on Vimeo.

Monday, August 29, 2011

UPHN - Query Health Summer Concert Series

New York’s Universal Public Health Node (UPHN) Initiative is a strategic organizational process, informatics approach and technical infrastructure to transform public health practice through health information exchange in New York. The UPHN enables the integration of the public health practice across the health enterprise as part of the business model for effective and economical health care delivery. UPHN helps improve the efficacy of public health practice through authorized program access to integrated longitudinal health information assets.  Ivan Gotham, Lee Jones and Vince Lewis present.


Query Health - UPHN Presentation from S&I Framework on Vimeo.

Thursday, August 18, 2011

The August HIT Standards Committee Meeting

By John Halamka, Life as a Healthcare CIO

 The August meeting of the HIT Standards Committee (the 28th meeting of this FACA) was a milestone in parsimony.   As you'll see, we approved a set of vocabulary recommendations and public health standards that represent harmony as well the fewest number of standards possible for the intended purpose. 

Since April, we've been working hard on Summer Camp.   At our September meeting, we'll wrap up all that work and hand off the finished standards recommendations to ONC for regulation writing.

Per our Summer Camp plan, the August meeting included final recommendations on vocabulary standards for quality measures, final recommendations on all public health transactions, preliminary recommendations on patient matching, and preliminary recommendations on transport/security standards.   We also heard from the Standards and Interoperability Framework team about their work and the Implementation Workgroup on their review of Certification Criteria.

This was a powerful meeting, discussing the standards that so many people have been working on for the past decade - one vocabulary standard for each class of data used in quality measures, one approach to public health transactions, one approach to transfer of care summaries, one approach to laboratory results, and a building block approach to data transmission that supports the portfolio of health information exchange options.

We began with the final recommendations from the Clinical Quality Workgroup and Vocabulary Task force on vocabulary standards.   Per the marching orders we gave them, they selected one vocabulary standard for each domain - problems, medications, allergies, labs etc.    SNOMED-CT and LOINC are the default vocabularies used whenever possible.   The committee approved these recommendations by consensus with 2 caveats

-the Implementation Workgroup will be charged with ongoing review of the implementation burden of using these standards in a variety of settings
-the September meeting of the HIT Standards Committee will include discussion of a transition plan for those vocabulary standards required for Stage 1 that are being retired/replaced in Stage 2.

Marc Overhage presented best practices for patient matching, identifying the metadata that should be standardized in patient records and health information exchange.   These recommendations are complementary to the metadata standard recommendations in the Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, enabling stakeholders to optimize a patient matching strategy as needed for their applications using best practices and evidence from industry experience.

Chris Chute presented the recommendations for public health standards  - one HL7 2.51 implementation guide for surveillance, one HL7 2.51 implementation guide for immunizations and one HL7 2.51 implementation guide for reportable labs.   The optionality specified in meaningful use stage 1 was eliminated and the end result are simple un-ambiguous implementation guides for public health.

Dixie Baker presented the preliminary recommendations for building blocks that support data exchange in both "push" and "pull" models.   The key innovation in Dixie's is the process for reviewing existing standards for appropriateness, adoption, maturity, and currency.

Jitin Asnaani from ONC presented the S&I Framework update including Certificates, Lab Results, Transitions of Care, and Provider Directories. These will be reviewed and hopefully turned into guidance for ONC in the next few months.

Finally, Judy Murphy and Liz Johnson presented their work on certification criteria.

A remarkable meeting from a world class team.  I'm proud to be a part of it!

Monday, August 15, 2011

hQuery - Query Health Summer Concert Series

Andy Gregorowicz presents MITRE’s work on hQuery. hQuery uses pervasive internet-based technologies to deliver flexible easy-to-understand queries and distributed ultra-large scale query execution capabilities.


Query Health - hQuery Presentation from S&I Framework on Vimeo.

Tuesday, August 9, 2011

PopMedNet - Query Health Summer Concert Series

PopMedNet uses distributed networks to analyze data from multiple organizations in order to aggregate information for secondary use (use other than direct patient care or administration) such as disease surveillance, comparative effectiveness, and medical product safety. In one example, the FDA identified final specifications for a query to monitor the cardiac outcomes of a particular drug. Using PopMedNet, the specs were distributed to 17 data partners with a combined 99 million individual users. Within an incredible turnaround time of two days a report was delivered outlining statistics about new users (including distributions by age, sex, year, and health plan), first treatment exposure duration, and cardiac outcome diagnoses during treatment. Platt and Brown also emphasized the importance of governance among participants in a distributed network in order to perform successful queries. PopMedNet’s flexibility allows for each network of participants to create, administer and govern their own networks. However, this puts the responsibility of governance on the individual networks to determine the data standards and best practices for their needs. Therefore, the success of PopMedNet relies heavily on its support for the governance principles of the participating organizations.  Rich Platt and Jeff Brown of Harvard Medical School’s Department of Population Medicine present.


Query Health - PopMedNet Presentation from siframework on Vimeo.

Monday, July 25, 2011

Distributed population queries - a national priority

 By Rich Elmore, Initiative Coordinator
Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology

This August, ONC will be sponsoring the “Summer Concert Series” on the state-of-the-art of distributed population queries. The “Summer Concert Series” webinar presentations will provide tremendous insight from a real-world perspective to interested stakeholders on practitioners’ experience with distributed queries.     

Distributed population queries can be applied to public health surveillance, research, quality measures, chronic disease stratification and many other purposes.  These queries return aggregate information from a standard clinical information model, leaving protected health information safely behind the health care organizations’ firewalls. 

The use of distributed population queries for clinical insight has been hindered by organizational limitations on data sharing, inconsistencies in the expression of clinical concepts and lack of standards for distributed queries.  This has ultimately limited their use, with a few notable exceptions, to large healthcare organizations with more sophisticated IT infrastructures and deeper research budgets. 

One may ask “Why not just centralize the data?”  Well for one, for non-regulated purposes many healthcare organizations will choose not to loosen their control over their data.  Also, as a matter of principle, patient level data shouldn’t be exchanged when aggregate level information will do.  Finally, keeping data close to the source may improve adaptability to dynamic information needs and responsiveness to patient information sharing preferences. 

As we approach critical mass of deployments of certified and standardized Electronic Health Record (EHR) systems, we may for the first time be able to consider broader use of distributed population queries.  EHR certification standards require greater adherence to standardized vocabularies and information exchange structures.  While challenges with comparative data will remain, Meaningful Use Stage 2 will likely further improve vocabulary, message and transport standards.  

As an example of distributed queries, Wes Rishel recently explored the changing public health reporting needs during an epidemic.  He suggested use of distributed population queries to “send questions to the data.”  

For another example, until recently the most extensive research to identify comorbidities for autism patients was a multi-year study on 163 patients.  Zak Kohane’s new work on autism patients and comorbidities used distributed queries across the i2b2 SHRINE network linking 4 Boston hospitals.  By tapping into a much larger patient population, his analysis provided greater insight into the comorbidities.  The time required to conduct the research was 3 weeks.   Distributed queries delivered these deeper insights  by reaching an order of magnitude more patients and did so in two orders of magnitude less time. 

Query Health, a public/private partnership project, will be launched in September to take some practical first steps towards this national priority.  The ultimate goal of the Query Health initiative will be to define the standards and services to better enable the use of this distributed approach. 

Please mark your calendars for the “Summer Concert Series” in August and the Query Health project launch on September 6th at 3 PM ET.  Visit the Query Health web site for more information on these events.   

Thursday, July 21, 2011

The July HIT Standards Committee Meeting

by John Halamka, Life as a Healthcare CIO


Farzad Mostashari, national coordinator for healthcare IT, began the meeting with a discussion of the issues we have always faced while harmonizing standards.  Standards that are widely adopted by the marketplace and are well tested make harmonization easy.  However, many standards are mature but not widely adopted or novel but not well tested.   We want to encourage innovation and use market adoption as a measure of our success.   It's clear that at times we'll have to consider new standards that seem very reasonable for the purpose intended and test them in real world scenarios before forcing top down adoption through regulation.   Bottom up adoption of standards that are implemented and improved by stakeholders is a better approach.  

Per the Standards Summer Camp schedule, the July HIT Standards Committee meeting focused on

Vocabulary recommendations 
ePrescribing of discharged medications recommendations
Patient Matching recommendations
Syndromic Surveillance recommendations

Jim Walker, chair of the Clinical Quality workgroup, presented an overview of the vocabulary work done to support all our clinical coordination and quality measurement activities.  The charter for the group was to select the minimum number of vocabulary standards with the minimum number of values to meet the requirements of meaningful use stages 2 and 3.   Reducing the number of standards makes mapping between different vocabularies much easier.    The workgroup used SNOMED-CT and LOINC wherever possible and tried to select one vocabulary per domain (allergies, labs, medications etc).   Examples of their selections include

Adverse Drug effect - RxNorm for medications, SNOMED-CT for non-medication substances, SNOMED-CT for severity of reaction

Patient characteristics - ISO 639-2 for preferred language, HL7 for administrative gender, PHIN-VADS (Centers for Disease Control) for Race/Ethnicity

Condition/Diagnosis/Problem - SNOMED-CT

Non-lab Diagnostic study - LOINC for name, SNOMED-CT for appropriate findings, UCUM for Units

A rich discussion followed.  Points of concern included:
*Using RxNorm for all medications including vaccines, even though CVX is the required vaccine vocabulary for Meaningful Use stage 1.   We clarified this with an example from Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center:

BIDMC uses First Data Bank as the medication vocabulary for its internal systems.  However, when BIDMC sends clinical summaries, it maps FDB to RxNorm for all drug names.  When BIDMC sends immunization records to public health, it uses CVX codes.   Thus, the HIT Standards Committee will not specify the vocabularies used within enterprise applications, just those vocabularies that are needed for specific purposes when data is transmitted between entities.

Next, Doug Fridsma began a discussion of our Summer Camp items, noting the many projects of the S&I framework are proceeding according to plan.

Scott Robertson presented the work of the Discharge Medications Power Team.  They recommended HL7 and NCPDP script as reasonable standards for sending discharge medication orders to hospital pharmacies and retail pharmacies.

Discussion followed regarding two specific points - their recommendations did not include a specific version of HL7, since existing Medicare Part D regulations do not specify an HL7 version.  The power team will make additional more specific HL7 recommendations.   There was discussion about the  specific aspects of RxNorm that constrain the way dose and route are specified.   The HIT Standards Committee members felt additional work was needed before mandating this level of specificity, so our recommendations will include RxNorm for medication name, but not additional specificity for dose and route vocabularies at this time.

Next, Marc Overhage presented the recommendations of thePatient Matching Power Team.   The scope of the Patient Matching work is to provide guidance to implementers who want to understand best practices for the use of demographics in machine to machine matching of patient identity.   Per the RAND Report, use of different fields results in variation of specificity and sensitivity.   Some fields such as social security number (or a subset of it) greatly increase specificity, resulting in fewer false positives such as matching the wrong patient.   However, social security number is controversial because of the potential for identity theft and the fact that immigrants may not have one.   The final report will take into account all these observations.

Chris Chute presented the recommendations of the Surveillance Implementation Guide Power Team, which aims to specify one implementation guide for each public health transaction.  They are studying the difference between HL7 2.31 and 2.51 as well as considering the potential for public health entities to use CDA constructs.

Dixie Baker presented a project plan for the NwHIN Power Team,which aims to specify a set of building blocks for secure transport of data in multiple architectures.

Finally, Judy Murphy and Liz Johnson presented their plans for the Implementation Workgroup, collecting lessons learned from  certification and attestation.

We're on track with Summer Camp.  Our next meeting in August will include the final recommendations for

Simple Lab Results 
Transitions of Care 
CDA Cleanup
Patient Matching
Vocabulary

Every meeting with the HIT Standards Committee (this was our 27th) brings us closer as a working team.   We're transparent and passionate, openly sharing all the issues and concerns about the standards we're selecting.  Coordination with all the moving parts (ONC, Policy Committee, S&I Framework)  keeps getting better and better.

Thus far, Summer Camp is a winner and I am confident we'll meet all our September deadlines for offering recommendations to ONC in preparation for Meaningful Use Stage 2 regulations.